Lately world leaders have denounced the free market and the era of American capitalism. This is nothing new as it has happened for 25 years. You should note that during this period the United States has had the largest economic expansion in world history and has prospered because of it. Sadly, the leaders of the United States are now joining their foreign counterparts and are blaming low taxes and the free market for our current economic trouble.
I have two questions.
One, how exactly is it possible that our free market system takes the blame for the current economic crisis when the economic sectors that caused it were never free at all?
Two, how exactly do low taxes get blamed for our staggering debt accumulation when all the data shows that government revenue has increased because of them, and GDP growth has risen as well?
Of course none of these so called “leaders” can explain this phenomenon. Allow me to briefly tackle both questions.
The housing bubble that has now burst was a direct result of government intervention in the housing market. There was never a free market in housing, and therefore the free market cannot be blamed for its collapse. Government policies mandated loans be given, (at incredibly low rates set by the Federal Reserve) and then the same government advocated the sale and purchase of those loans by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. This created a disjointed market where one player (the government via Fannie and Freddie) had virtually unlimited funds to buy mortgage backed securities. This gave literally anyone the ability to make a loan, and never have to worry about getting it paid back to them since they were planning on selling that loan all along. They were selling to Fannie and Freddie. Soon, even they could not sustain their buying of these bad loans. Enter Wall Street, who had seen the money that was being made and joined the party. This was anything but a free market. There are many other examples besides just housing, but I have other things to do right now.
The government is currently pleading for us to go out and spend money, but of course no one is listening since it is beyond dumb to spend and spend when your already in too much debt. Naturally the consumer is retrenching. The government however is trying to fill that void with their own spending. Perhaps, had the government not taken all our money through a variety of taxes we would actually have it to spend. How can people blame low taxes when they aren’t even low when compared to the rest of the world? How can people blame tax cuts when they have increased government revenue by stimulating economic activity. All one has to do is read the publicly available government economic data. I know that’s not the best way to spend your free time, but its all right there.
If you want to live in a European style economic system you will be in for a rude awakening. In America, we live better then the rest of the world for a reason. It is not an accident. It is because we have embraced the free market, lower taxes, less regulation, and fierce competition while the rest of the world by and large has not. Now, that is changing due to our leadership and if it is allowed to continue we will suffer. We can always recover, but depending on the amount of damage it might take so long to do it that we end up dieing broke.
